This is the first article since he won the Nobel Prize. Congratulations my friend.
Op-Ed Columnist
Let’s Get Fiscal
comments
writePost();
new_york_times:http://www.nytimes.com/2008/10/17/opinion/17krugman.html
if (acm.cc) acm.cc.write();
By PAUL KRUGMAN
Published: October 16, 2008
The Dow is surging! No, it’s plunging! No, it’s surging! No, it’s ...
Post a Comment »
Nevermind. While the manic-depressive stock market is dominating the headlines, the more important story is the grim news coming in about the real economy. It’s now clear that rescuing the banks is just the beginning: the nonfinancial economy is also in desperate need of help.
And to provide that help, we’re going to have to put some prejudices aside. It’s politically fashionable to rant against government spending and demand fiscal responsibility. But right now, increased government spending is just what the doctor ordered, and concerns about the budget deficit should be put on hold.
Before I get there, let’s talk about the economic situation.
Just this week, we learned that retail sales have fallen off a cliff, and so has industrial production. Unemployment claims are at steep-recession levels, and the Philadelphia Fed’s manufacturing index is falling at the fastest pace in almost 20 years. All signs point to an economic slump that will be nasty, brutish — and long.
How nasty? The unemployment rate is already above 6 percent (and broader measures of underemployment are in double digits). It’s now virtually certain that the unemployment rate will go above 7 percent, and quite possibly above 8 percent, making this the worst recession in a quarter-century.
And how long? It could be very long indeed.
Think about what happened in the last recession, which followed the bursting of the late-1990s technology bubble. On the surface, the policy response to that recession looks like a success story. Although there were widespread fears that the United States would experience a Japanese-style “lost decade,” that didn’t happen: the Federal Reserve was able to engineer a recovery from that recession by cutting interest rates.
But the truth is that we were looking Japanese for quite a while: the Fed had a hard time getting traction. Despite repeated interest rate cuts, which eventually brought the federal funds rate down to just 1 percent, the unemployment rate just kept on rising; it was more than two years before the job picture started to improve. And when a convincing recovery finally did come, it was only because Alan Greenspan had managed to replace the technology bubble with a housing bubble.
Now the housing bubble has burst in turn, leaving the financial landscape strewn with wreckage. Even if the ongoing efforts to rescue the banking system and unfreeze the credit markets work — and while it’s early days yet, the initial results have been disappointing — it’s hard to see housing making a comeback any time soon. And if there’s another bubble waiting to happen, it’s not obvious. So the Fed will find it even harder to get traction this time.
In other words, there’s not much Ben Bernanke can do for the economy. He can and should cut interest rates even more — but nobody expects this to do more than provide a slight economic boost.
On the other hand, there’s a lot the federal government can do for the economy. It can provide extended benefits to the unemployed, which will both help distressed families cope and put money in the hands of people likely to spend it. It can provide emergency aid to state and local governments, so that they aren’t forced into steep spending cuts that both degrade public services and destroy jobs. It can buy up mortgages (but not at face value, as John McCain has proposed) and restructure the terms to help families stay in their homes.
And this is also a good time to engage in some serious infrastructure spending, which the country badly needs in any case. The usual argument against public works as economic stimulus is that they take too long: by the time you get around to repairing that bridge and upgrading that rail line, the slump is over and the stimulus isn’t needed. Well, that argument has no force now, since the chances that this slump will be over anytime soon are virtually nil. So let’s get those projects rolling.
Will the next administration do what’s needed to deal with the economic slump? Not if Mr. McCain pulls off an upset. What we need right now is more government spending — but when Mr. McCain was asked in one of the debates how he would deal with the economic crisis, he answered: “Well, the first thing we have to do is get spending under control.”
If Barack Obama becomes president, he won’t have the same knee-jerk opposition to spending. But he will face a chorus of inside-the-Beltway types telling him that he has to be responsible, that the big deficits the government will run next year if it does the right thing are unacceptable.
He should ignore that chorus. The responsible thing, right now, is to give the economy the help it needs. Now is not the time to worry about the deficit.
Friday, October 17, 2008
Labels
- Civil Society (478)
- Liar's Poker by Michael Lewis (342)
- Hot Air (327)
- Heating Degree Days (160)
- Good Writing (153)
- natural gas (148)
- Deregulation of Electricity (139)
- Cramer Yesterday (134)
- Paul Krugman (128)
- Masters of the Universe (102)
- baselinescenerio.com (101)
- Countrywide (95)
- madoff (88)
- tech tips (76)
- aggregation (72)
- health care (63)
- trading again (63)
- Saakashvilli (59)
- Duke Energy (58)
- Trading Natural Gas and Other Futures and Derivatives (58)
- bailout (55)
- friedman (53)
- David Brooks (52)
- e-bills (52)
- Not Hot Air (51)
- simon johnson (50)
- Home Buyer (45)
- goldman sachs. (45)
- Leverage (43)
- Bear Stearns (39)
- Gretchen Morgenson (36)
- aig (36)
- herbert (35)
- real estate (33)
- GE (29)
- derivatives (29)
- Cramer Today (28)
- confessions of a pattern day-trader (28)
- gs (28)
- 885 Greenville (27)
- etf's (27)
- brooks (26)
- CNBC Today (25)
- Crash of 1987 (24)
- Rush Limbaugh (24)
- rich (23)
- How to Read This Blog (22)
- saackashvili (22)
- crash now (21)
- Clarence Thomas (20)
- kristoff (20)
- Nocera (19)
- William F. Buckley Jr. (18)
- cohen (17)
- credit default swaps (17)
- dowd (17)
- lehman (17)
- The Big Short by Michael Lewis (16)
- citicorp (16)
- hedge funds (16)
- obama (16)
- Charlie Rose (15)
- collins (15)
- cramer last night (15)
- globe_mail (15)
- banks (14)
- dreier (14)
- flynn's oil (14)
- georgia (14)
- kristol (14)
- Banc of America (13)
- Cramer and October 8 (13)
- Gold (13)
- Jimmy Rogers (13)
- The Current Stock Market and Reporting Therein (13)
- Warren Buffett (13)
- geithner (13)
- Bill Gross (12)
- Norris (12)
- Value of Diversification (12)
- c (12)
- fifth third (12)
- stimulus plan (12)
- American Energy (11)
- Auchincloss (11)
- bill moyers (11)
- david f swensen (11)
- humor (11)
- margaret wente (11)
- nakedshorts (11)
- pattern day trader (11)
- Ah Enron (10)
- alternative investments (10)
- yale (10)
- Energy Savings for Residential Home (9)
- Paulson (9)
- aig.credit default swaps (9)
- bond funds (9)
- investment advisors (9)
- realtors(R) (9)
- toxic (9)
- Misleading CNBC Ads (8)
- Why I Was Too Busy (8)
- canada (8)
- carlos celdran (8)
- consuelo mack (8)
- dead_of_winter (8)
- fifth_third (8)
- jp morgan (8)
- larry summers (8)
- morgan stanley (8)
- rubin (8)
- wolfe (8)
- Amaranth (7)
- Barefoot Advertising (7)
- Cooling Degree Days (7)
- Glengarry (7)
- Judge Cudahy (7)
- No Hot Air smart grid (7)
- Weakening Dollar (7)
- james kwak (7)
- pogue (7)
- reflects (7)
- symmes township (7)
- what we learn when special people die (7)
- Municipality Bankruptcies (6)
- Notary Signing Agents (6)
- Private Equity (6)
- andrew ross serkin (6)
- bogle of vanguard (6)
- civil rights (6)
- fannie and freddie (6)
- gm (6)
- health (6)
- italy (6)
- keynes (6)
- mortgage brokers (6)
- stan chesley (6)
- susan boyle (6)
- volker (6)
- ; CNBC Today (5)
- Actual Laurel and Greenville (5)
- Cost Per Megawatt (5)
- Deregulation (5)
- Judith Warner (5)
- Merrill Lynch (5)
- Phil Gramm (5)
- The Dollar (5)
- auction rate securities (5)
- bonds (5)
- cramer's crash checklist 2010 (5)
- credit cards (5)
- dan gearino (5)
- dominion (5)
- dulley (5)
- high frequency trading (5)
- iou (5)
- iran (5)
- john lanchester (5)
- joseph cassano (5)
- kesselschlacht (5)
- libor (5)
- mybesttime (5)
- natural gas is not like oil (5)
- palin (5)
- philippines (5)
- sec (5)
- stanford (5)
- ted kennedy (5)
- Gail Collins (4)
- Hunter S. Thompson (4)
- Si burick (4)
- US Dollar (4)
- art cashin (4)
- blow (4)
- buffett (4)
- don marshall (4)
- dwell (4)
- economics (4)
- finances (4)
- fraud (4)
- green township (4)
- grisham (4)
- harry markopolos (4)
- heating oil (4)
- hillary (4)
- investment banks (4)
- john c bogle (4)
- pajama traders (4)
- rider fpp (4)
- soros. friedman (4)
- sotomayor (4)
- subprime meltdown (4)
- supreme court (4)
- tarp (4)
- where we live out lives (4)
- 1998 (3)
- 970 laurel (3)
- Fiscal Stimulous (3)
- Paul Newman (3)
- Reich (3)
- The Associate (3)
- Thomas Frank (3)
- What a Ride Ye Gave Thee Shareholders (3)
- ackman (3)
- bp (3)
- burry (3)
- calvin trillin (3)
- carlos slim. masters of the universe (3)
- cdo (3)
- cds's (3)
- checklist (3)
- christopher buckley (3)
- collapse (3)
- commodities (3)
- david muth (3)
- doug worple (3)
- duhigg (3)
- duke energy retail sales llc (3)
- elizabeth warren (3)
- euro (3)
- flash crash (3)
- g-20 (3)
- glendale (3)
- goolsbee (3)
- gs; Liar's Poker by Michael Lewis (3)
- gs; goldman sachs. (3)
- hank greenberg (3)
- institutional investor (3)
- insurance companies (3)
- law firms (3)
- manila (3)
- mcnees (3)
- meredith whitney (3)
- middle east (3)
- movies (3)
- new yorker (3)
- option arms (3)
- paul daugherty (3)
- procter (3)
- reagan (3)
- ritchard posner (3)
- steve martin (3)
- stimulous plan (3)
- terrorism (3)
- toqueville (3)
- trust (3)
- wendell potter (3)
- words (3)
- Bernie schaeffer (2)
- Buddy (2)
- Editor's Selection (2)
- Frank DeFord (2)
- Gasparino (2)
- George Vecsey (2)
- Geothermal (2)
- God (2)
- Greenspan (2)
- Latest Carry Trade (2)
- Railroads (2)
- Remnick (2)
- Rich.reflects (2)
- Spitzer (2)
- The Very Crux (2)
- Wachovia (2)
- Weather Futures (2)
- a heddgie (2)
- abacus (2)
- aep (2)
- andreww ross serkin (2)
- arthur nadel (2)
- auto task force (2)
- barcelona (2)
- barrons (2)
- barton (2)
- bernanke (2)
- beth smith (2)
- biden (2)
- bill black (2)
- black swan (2)
- blood pressure (2)
- bridge (2)
- brooks-Simon (2)
- bruce abel (2)
- bubbles (2)
- cheever (2)
- chris dodd (2)
- christopher walken (2)
- community reinvestment act (2)
- corporate bonds (2)
- cramer's list (2)
- crash of 1929 (2)
- crash of 2:45 p.m. (2)
- cursing mommy (2)
- daugherty (2)
- donttrythisonyourhome.blogspot.com (2)
- duk (2)
- economix (2)
- entrepreneur (2)
- eu (2)
- fasb (2)
- fast money last night (2)
- financial advisors (2)
- financial crisis inquiry commission (2)
- fool's gold (2)
- glanville (2)
- glass-steagall (2)
- guessing cramer (2)
- hal mcCoy (2)
- house of cards (2)
- hugh laury (2)
- ian frazier (2)
- imf (2)
- immelt (2)
- indymac (2)
- iolta (2)
- jamie dimon (2)
- jimmy cayne (2)
- john mack (2)
- kellerman (2)
- lobbying (2)
- loonie (2)
- magnetar (2)
- marcellus shale (2)
- marselus shale (2)
- mcCain (2)
- medicare (2)
- merton.mit (2)
- milton friedman (2)
- neil bortz (2)
- notes from natural gas country (2)
- nuclear power generation (2)
- patrick french (2)
- paumgarten (2)
- pelosi (2)
- peter bernstein (2)
- phil in the mountains of kyushu (2)
- phillip schuck (2)
- philosophy (2)
- pnc (2)
- power grid (2)
- ratigan (2)
- rebecca Worple pictures (2)
- regions financial (2)
- regulation (2)
- rick santelli (2)
- robert shiller (2)
- rolling stone (2)
- schumer (2)
- schwab (2)
- securitization (2)
- seeking alpha (2)
- shadow banking system (2)
- sir allen stanford (2)
- south ossetia (2)
- stanley fish (2)
- stated income loans (2)
- steen (2)
- stress tests (2)
- structured finance (2)
- taleb (2)
- talf (2)
- too big to fail (2)
- treasury (2)
- troubled asset recovery plan (2)
- trusts (2)
- twitter (2)
- veverka (2)
- walter noel (2)
- water (2)
- weatherization (2)
- wells fargo (2)
- whitney tilson (2)
- william cohan (2)
- world affairs (2)
- 1040 (1)
- 12 angry men (1)
- 60 minutes (1)
- Daschle (1)
- December (1)
- Detroit (1)
- Dirty tricks (1)
- Dmitry Orlov (1)
- Econned (1)
- Electricity (1)
- EnCana (1)
- February (1)
- Gold Standard (1)
- Irremedial (1)
- January (1)
- Jr. (1)
- Judith Timson (1)
- Kevin Hassett (1)
- McFadden Act (1)
- National City (1)
- Negrych (1)
- No There There (1)
- November (1)
- Peter Baker (1)
- Rob portman (1)
- September (1)
- Surowiecki (1)
- T. Boone Pickens (1)
- TWITTER DAY capers (1)
- Teddy Roosevelt (1)
- The Flash Guys (1)
- VaR (1)
- WEP (1)
- WPA (1)
- ` (1)
- aa (1)
- aaron pressman (1)
- above the law (1)
- acorn (1)
- adwords (1)
- afghanistan (1)
- africa trip (1)
- aging (1)
- ai (1)
- ajay kapur (1)
- ajit jain (1)
- aligned interest partnerships (1)
- allegheny (1)
- ambient (1)
- american electric power (1)
- anandarko (1)
- andrew j hall (1)
- andrew lo (1)
- andy redleaf (1)
- anne hathaway (1)
- annuities (1)
- apc (1)
- attorney review (1)
- ayp (1)
- ayres (1)
- bachus (1)
- barofsky (1)
- baseball (1)
- basis_of_stocks (1)
- ben stein (1)
- best line of the day (1)
- bill ayres (1)
- bill gates (1)
- bill o'reilly (1)
- bill youngclaus (1)
- blackstone group (1)
- blankfein (1)
- blodget (1)
- blodgett (1)
- bob woodward (1)
- books and entertainment (1)
- brown-kaufman (1)
- bruce harlamert (1)
- bully points (1)
- buy and hold (1)
- california (1)
- canadian banks (1)
- canadian dollar (1)
- carlyle group (1)
- carol loomis (1)
- casa batllo picture (1)
- cds.money market (1)
- charles ortel (1)
- charles taylor (1)
- chesapeake energy (1)
- chicago (1)
- china (1)
- christopher hitchens (1)
- city-data (1)
- cleaving in two (1)
- closing costs (1)
- cloud computing (1)
- cng (1)
- cobra (1)
- colin powell (1)
- collar funds (1)
- colors (1)
- columbia gas (1)
- commercial property (1)
- communitarian (1)
- conan obrien (1)
- concrete (1)
- conocophilips (1)
- consumer financial product agency (1)
- contracts (1)
- cooking (1)
- corporate law (1)
- cottage ownership (1)
- cox (1)
- creditaig.credit default swaps (1)
- daily normals (1)
- dan kucera (1)
- david corn (1)
- david einhorn (1)
- david faber (1)
- david frum (1)
- david gray (1)
- david gu (1)
- david kessler (1)
- dayton daily news (1)
- default option (1)
- deficit (1)
- discount rate mismatch (1)
- divorce (1)
- dmitri young (1)
- douthat (1)
- dov seidman (1)
- due diligence (1)
- dzhugashvili (1)
- earmarks (1)
- earthquake (1)
- edmund andrews (1)
- education (1)
- effrat (1)
- el-erian (1)
- ellen brown (1)
- emma (1)
- equities (1)
- eric holder (1)
- estate planning (1)
- estate taxes (1)
- ethics (1)
- european union (1)
- everything relates to everything (1)
- ewe reinhardt (1)
- exceptionalism (1)
- extend and pretend (1)
- ezra merkin (1)
- f (1)
- facebook fiasco (1)
- fairenergyohio.org (1)
- fault swaps (1)
- feith (1)
- financial engineering (1)
- finland (1)
- first energy (1)
- fitzgerald (1)
- fixed income (1)
- fonts (1)
- food (1)
- foreclosures (1)
- fracking (1)
- fuchs (1)
- futures chain (1)
- game face (1)
- gary kaminski (1)
- gasoline (1)
- gawande (1)
- gazprom (1)
- gerry spence (1)
- glen beck (1)
- good writing; what we learn when special people die (1)
- greek debt (1)
- gregg (1)
- gs; (1)
- gwyn morgan (1)
- hdd (1)
- heroes (1)
- hilda solis (1)
- home buyer tax credit (1)
- homes (1)
- igs (1)
- index funds (1)
- india (1)
- inflation (1)
- infrastructure (1)
- interest rate swaps (1)
- investment neighborhood concept (1)
- iphone+facebook (1)
- ireland (1)
- irs (1)
- james simons (1)
- john burns (1)
- john cassidy (1)
- john_paulson (1)
- jon stewart (1)
- jose manuel tesoro (1)
- julian epstein (1)
- kagan (1)
- karl icahn (1)
- kate middleton (1)
- kate winslet (1)
- ken lewis (1)
- kevin drum (1)
- lafley (1)
- lawyering (1)
- leonie benesch (1)
- liddy (1)
- limiting wall street salaries (1)
- linda greenhouse (1)
- liquidity (1)
- listen up (1)
- lists (1)
- livingwiththeoldies (1)
- lynn a stout (1)
- macArthur (1)
- madmoneyrecap.com (1)
- maira kalman (1)
- malcolm gladwell (1)
- managed futures (1)
- manhattan institute (1)
- mark everson (1)
- mark-to-market rule (1)
- martin act (1)
- mcallen texas (1)
- mcconnell (1)
- meachem (1)
- medicaid (1)
- memory lane (1)
- mergers and acquisitions (1)
- mf global;corzine; Masters of the Universe (1)
- michael jackson (1)
- mike demmer (1)
- mike mayo (1)
- mit (1)
- mit technology review (1)
- mold (1)
- mommy (1)
- money market funds (1)
- moral hazard (1)
- mother jones (1)
- mozilo (1)
- msnbc (1)
- muppets (1)
- mutual funds (1)
- myth of the great war (1)
- nagornay (1)
- naipaul (1)
- nassim taleb (1)
- nationalization (1)
- ncaa (1)
- new construction (1)
- nicholas dawidoff (1)
- nick grealy (1)
- nopec (1)
- not misleading cnbc ads (1)
- not sure (1)
- november 2010 elections (1)
- nymex (1)
- oil sands (1)
- oil spill in gulf (1)
- options (1)
- orange county (1)
- orman (1)
- p&g (1)
- packer (1)
- pakistan (1)
- passive houses (1)
- patrick-taylor plan (1)
- pension funds (1)
- peter weinberg (1)
- phillip blond (1)
- phisosophy (1)
- pico iyer (1)
- pictures (1)
- planes (1)
- plutomomics (1)
- powers of attorney (1)
- prechter (1)
- primal image (1)
- primary care doctors (1)
- procedure (1)
- progress energy (1)
- quants (1)
- queen elizabeth (1)
- quiet zones (1)
- rahm (1)
- randazzo (1)
- random sayings (1)
- randum notes; Hot Air (1)
- ratings (1)
- regulatory capture (1)
- renminbi (1)
- rent scams (1)
- repo 105 (1)
- residential counteroffer (1)
- restoring wireless (1)
- retail (1)
- reunion (1)
- rice v igs (1)
- roger altman (1)
- ron insana (1)
- ross serkin (1)
- roubina (1)
- rtichard posner (1)
- russian winter (1)
- s and p (1)
- sallie mae (1)
- sarah brightman (1)
- saskia de brauw (1)
- saturday night live (1)
- satyajit das (1)
- schadenfreude (1)
- science (1)
- sean miller (1)
- segal (1)
- silver (1)
- single payer system (1)
- singleism (1)
- sistine chapel (1)
- small business (1)
- smart metering (1)
- soros (1)
- speculation (1)
- springfield township (1)
- stalin (1)
- steele (1)
- steidlmayer (1)
- stenfors (1)
- steven g breyer (1)
- steven schwartzman (1)
- stewart (1)
- stiglitz (1)
- strauss-kahn (1)
- strictly local (1)
- susan jacoby (1)
- tabula rasa (1)
- tanenhaus (1)
- tanta (1)
- target date funds (1)
- taxes (1)
- ted forstmann (1)
- ten things (1)
- tett (1)
- thamel (1)
- the haggler (1)
- the reader (1)
- thomas jefferson (1)
- thomas lee (1)
- thomas montague (1)
- thomas ricks (1)
- timeline. laffley (1)
- timothy egan (1)
- tivo (1)
- tod_x;Duke Energy (1)
- todx (1)
- tom archdeacon (1)
- tom daschle (1)
- tom wilson.allstate (1)
- trains and automobiles (1)
- travel insurance (1)
- ultra (1)
- ung (1)
- united states steel (1)
- vanity fair (1)
- vatican (1)
- verizon (1)
- victoria falls (1)
- victorian homes (1)
- w (1)
- wall street (1)
- washinton mutual (1)
- whitebox (1)
- wilpon (1)
- wtrg (1)
- wwII. flash crash (1)
- www.rule26a1.com (1)
- x (1)
- year_end (1)
- zambia (1)
- zardari (1)