Friday, September 4, 2009

Judith Timson -- Remember Her as a Good Writer For the Globe and Mail

(c) 2009 F. Bruce Abel

This article highlights athe best writing of the Globe and Mail, with a leisurely piece that you

do not really find in the U.S. daily press.

And what a story. Canada is small enough for ample reporters to dig and to bring out the quirky facts of every interesting story.


News
Business
Investing
Sports
Life
+ Show all sections
Help
Login
Register
Profile
Logout




Search People at canpages.caPeople
by Canpages.ca

News
National
Politics
World
Opinion
Arts
Tech
Business
Industry News
Small Business
Commentary
Managing
Investing
My Watchlist
Markets
Funds & ETFs
Commodities
Investing Ideas
Personal Finance
Sports
Hockey
Baseball
Basketball
Football
Golf
Soccer
More Sports
Commentary
Life
Food & Wine
Family & Relationships
Work & Money
Travel
Health & Fitness
Style
Features
Advisor
Autos
Blogs
Books
Deaths
Documentaries
Education
Globe Investor Gold
Podcasts
Real Estate
Special Reports
Video
Weather
Services
Careers
Globe Plus
Personals
Get the Globe
Alerts
eReader
Mobile
Newsletters
Paper Subscription
RSS (news feeds)
Globe Recognition
Customer Care Centre
Contact Us (web)
Contact Us (print)
Staff
Vacation Stops
Marketplace
Appointment Notices
Classifieds
Newspaper Ads
Advertise with us
Newspaper
Magazine
Online

Food & Wine
Family & Relationships
Work & Money
Travel
Health & Fitness
Style
Personals
Featured:
Weather
Video
Blogs
RSS Feeds
Globe Books
TV listings
Globe on Twitter
Columnists
TIFF 2009
Judith Timson
Michael Bryant: The story none of us can stop talking about
Beneath the facts of the Bryant case lies a bubbling cauldron of social resentments, mistrust of authority and other prejudices
Share with friends
Close
Email

Other ways of sharing:


Add to Delicious
Submit post to Digg.com
Seed this post at Newsvine
Print or License
Close
Print this page
License this story
Recommend
165 Times
See also:
New surveillance footage in Bryant case
Girlfriend of dead cyclist questions police refusal to drive him home
Christie Blatchford: Bryant's story shocking, sobering – far too common

Column

Video

Comments




Judith Timson
Last updated on Friday, Sep. 04, 2009 03:40AM EDT
It is the story that none of us can stop talking about.
The horrific Michael Bryant case, in which the former Ontario attorney-general has been charged in the death of a bicycle courier in Toronto, has been tidily summed up just about everywhere as our own Bonfire of the Vanities . It's an apt comparison, because beneath the facts lies a bubbling cauldron of social resentments, mistrust of authority and other prejudices that may well tell us more about ourselves than about anything else.
Here are those facts: Mr. Bryant, 43, Ontario's former attorney-general and a political golden boy, has been charged with criminal negligence causing death, and dangerous driving following the death of Darcy Allan Sheppard, 33, a bicycle courier with whom he had an altercation Monday evening along a tony stretch of Toronto's Bloor Street. Mr. Sheppard was seen clinging to Mr. Bryant's car and eventually died after he fell off.
It's been fascinating in this very urban tale of privilege, character, rage and tragedy to see how, like a fast-moving bowling game, certain pins have quickly been set up and just as quickly knocked down.
First, Mr. Sheppard, the bicycle courier was seen to be a wonderful funny guy, a merry warrior in the often intense subculture of bicycle couriers, a father about to get his life in order. Then he was a drunk with an alleged criminal past and “a history of violence” according to one report published in the Edmonton Sun. He had already been in the back of a police cruiser that night as cops tried to figure out what to do with him. Even though his girlfriend told the media Mr. Sheppard had been too drunk to operate his bike, the police sent him on his way.
And first Mr. Bryant, Harvard educated, recently appointed to a prestigious economic post in Toronto, was, in his sleek black Saab convertible with his accomplished wife, entertainment lawyer Susan Abramovitch at his side, viewed as the very epitome of the luxe life. The couple, celebrating their 12th wedding anniversary, surely must have been coming from some glitzy Yorkville boîte, replete with fine food and a side order of entitlement.
But according to a Toronto Star interview with “a source close to the family,” the couple had instead eaten at a modest College Street shawarma joint (the bill apparently totalled $15), then walked on the beach and finally finished up at a Greek pastry shop on the Danforth, sitting in a café, talking as the late summer night cooled. A modest date that most of us could afford. One that incomprehensibly led to Mr. Sheppard being dragged by Mr. Bryant's car as it swerved into the wrong lane. After that it would be Mr. Bryant's turn to sit in the back of a police cruiser.
These images are confusing. They may well even be irrelevant. They certainly don't conform to the rich or poor, black or white, good or bad, powerful or victimized lens through which most of us are inclined to view this tragedy.
At first people wanted to talk about the dangerous and hostile relationship between cyclists and drivers. If you were a cyclist, your initial reaction was to side with the downed bicycle courier. Not so much if you were a motorist weary of cyclers' wrath.
Then the talk turned to moral judgment. “What a story” breathed one woman I met on the street. “I see he's already hired a spin doctor and unsavoury truths about the cyclist are starting to trickle out. Typical.”
“Did the cyclist really get him in a headlock?” a friend asked. “That says viable defence to me.”
Perhaps the key question that festered as hundreds of angry cyclists emotionally demonstrated at the scene of the accident: Will Mr. Bryant get special treatment?
Listen, they could resurrect Gandhi to specially prosecute this case, but if the former attorney-general prevails in his declaration of innocence, a sizable number of citizens will believe that the case was rigged from the moment Mr. Bryant was allowed to emerge from a night in custody to face the cameras, not unshaven and rumpled like most people, but impeccably turned out in a sharp suit and shirt and tie.
How frustrating that we will have to wait at least until mid-October to know the end of this sad tale, that in the meantime we will have to deal with more ambiguity and nuance, with not knowing which details matter and which are just the easy ways we have come to typecast our heroes and villains – not to mention voice our own frustrations. We may finally have to acknowledge that notwithstanding a Harvard degree or an alcohol problem, both of these human beings gave in to the wrong emotion at the wrong time. Yet of course only one lost his life.
Told that way, we are left with no clear villain – only colossal misjudgment in a human tragedy that reminds us what we don't want to think too closely about, lest it happen to us: Our lives are completely hostage to human frailty. That isn't the satisfying moral conclusion we want to draw from this story. But it's the one we've got.
Share with friends
Close
Email

Please enter a valid e-mail address
Please enter a comma delimited list of valid e-mail addresses
Other ways of sharing:


Add to Delicious
Submit post to Digg.com
Seed this post at Newsvine
Print or License
Close
Print this page
Recommend
165 Times
More recent pieces from Judith Timson
Turn off, tune in, get happy Monday, Aug. 31, 2009 12:00AM EDT
A Stanford University study released last week finds that staying focused and not multitasking is 'the next best thing' to happiness
No more pencils. No more books. No more teachers' dirty looks Monday, Aug. 24, 2009 12:00AM EDT
This will be the first September in 20 years I haven't sent a kid back to school
Get your rage the %@!# under control Monday, Aug. 17, 2009 09:00AM EDT
The nuclear level of anger that abounds these days makes us all tone-deaf to anyone else's point of view
It's the Hillary & Bill show. Deal with it Sunday, Aug. 09, 2009 06:56PM EDT
The U.S. power couple is gloriously equal. Yet, when we're not pitting Hill against Bill, we're accusing them of planning a ‘shadow presidency'
Tired at 21? Maybe it's all that darn texting Sunday, Aug. 02, 2009 07:03PM EDT
You're young, fit, gorgeous and busy – what have you got to be tired about? Generation Y is supposedly in the prime of their lives, but they can't stop using the T-word
Don't sentence M.T. as an adult Sunday, Jul. 26, 2009 05:06PM EDT
Who we are at 15 going on 16, is not who we will be at 25. If M.T. serves a mandatory life sentence in an adult prison, she will less likely become a better person, one who ultimately feels true remorse
How not to be the cottage guest from hell Monday, Jul. 20, 2009 09:40AM EDT
Plus, a few words on how to be a gracious host
We’ve made lemonade, but it sure tastes sour Monday, Jul. 13, 2009 10:20AM EDT
It's a season of silver linings, where the upbeat message seems to be: Hey, aren't we all having fun anyway, despite a massive economic turndown?
Weeping for strangers, not Jacko Monday, Jul. 06, 2009 07:02PM EDT
Canadian opera singer and actor Jan Rubes died, like many others, during the Michael Jackson frenzy. It's those deaths – not MJ's – that gave me a feeling of being human, being mortal, being connected with other people's pain and grief
New surveillance footage in Bryant case Thursday, Sep. 03, 2009 08:27AM EDT
Girlfriend of dead cyclist questions police refusal to drive him home Wednesday, Sep. 02, 2009 08:57PM EDT
Christie Blatchford: Bryant's story shocking, sobering – far too common
A search for answers in a cyclist's death Thursday, Sep. 03, 2009 10:12PM EDT
Bryant resigns as head of Invest Toronto Wednesday, Sep. 02, 2009 12:46PM EDT
Flowers, notes mark Toronto memorial for cyclist Wednesday, Sep. 02, 2009 12:37PM EDT
Drinking and cycling: Impaired and rolling on two wheels Thursday, Sep. 03, 2009 05:37PM EDT
var pluckCommentCloseReason = "We have closed comments on this story for legal reasons. We appreciate your understanding.";
Latest Comments
Comments have been disabledEditor's Note: We have closed comments on this story for legal reasons. We appreciate your understanding.
Posted by at
Labels: , ,

Labels